Charity Shield · Final

Manchester United v Manchester City

1–1

Saturday 10th August 2024 · Wembley · Att: 78,146

Manchester United drew 1–1 with Manchester City at Wembley (N) on Saturday 10th August 2024 in the Charity Shield. Alejandro Garnacho (82') scored for United. United were captained by Bruno Fernandes, and the referee was Jarred Gillett.

Timeline

Running score

Kick Off
Half Time
58' Facundo Pellistri for Maguire
58' Scott McTominay for Mount
59' Toby Collyer for Mainoo
59' Alejandro Garnacho for Diallo
68' Matheus Nunes
82' Alejandro Garnacho 1–0
83' Jadon Sancho for Rashford
85' Bernardo Silva
85' Alejandro Garnacho
89' Bernardo Silva 1–1
Full Time 1–1

Match Facts

44%

Possession

4-2-3-1

Formation

Jarred Gillett

Referee

Bruno Fernandes

Captain

Starting XI

Player

Substitutes

58' for Maguire

58' for Mount

59' for Mainoo

59' for Diallo

82'

Jadon Sancho

83' for Rashford

Manchester City Lineup

4-3-3

Starting XI

3 Rúben Dias CD-L

8 Mateo Kovacic CM

9 Erling Haaland F

11 Jérémy Doku LF

24 Josko Gvardiol LB

25 Manuel Akanji CD-R

31 Ederson G

52 Oscar Bobb RF

75 Nico O'Reilly RM

82 Rico Lewis RB

87 James McAtee LM

Substitutes

4 Kalvin Phillips

6 Nathan Aké on

17 Kevin De Bruyne on

18 Stefan Ortega

20 Bernardo Silva on ⚽

26 Savinho on

27 Matheus Nunes on

33 Scott Carson

78 Issa Kaboré

Opposition lineup via ESPN. Opposition players do not have profile pages on this site.

Managers

MUFC

Erik ten Hag

Manchester United

OPP

Josep Guardiola

Manchester City

Match Information

Man Utd

4-2-3-1

Formation

Manchester City

4-3-3

Man Utd Manchester City

44%

Possession

56%

United vs Manchester City History

Meeting 194 of 199

199

Played

Won

Drawn

Lost

280

Goals For

279

Goals Against

All-time record, from the first meeting on Saturday 3rd October 1891. After this match United had played Manchester City 194 times: 79W 54D 61L.

29 Oct 2023 L 0–3 PL 3 Mar 2024 L 1–3 PL 25 May 2024 W 2–1 FAC

10 Aug 2024 D 1–1 This match

15 Dec 2024 W 2–1 PL 6 Apr 2025 D 0–0 PL 14 Sep 2025 L 0–3 PL

All-time	P	W	D	L	F	A	Win%
Home	99	44	29	26	152	124	44.4
Away	94	35	25	34	121	145	37.2
Neutral	6	2	1	3	7	10	33.3

All 199 meetings with Manchester City →

Match results, lineups and goalscorers compiled from mufcinfo.com; advanced match statistics (xG, shots, possession) via FBref and FotMob where available. Last updated 29 September 2026. How we compile this data →