Charity Shield · Final

Manchester United v Aston Villa

4–0

Tuesday 22nd October 1957 · Old Trafford · Att: 27,293

Manchester United beat Aston Villa 4–0 at Old Trafford on Tuesday 22nd October 1957 in the Charity Shield. Tommy Taylor (50', 54', 70') and Johnny Berry (87') scored for United.

Timeline

Running score

Kick Off
Half Time
50' Tommy Taylor 1–0
54' Tommy Taylor 2–0
70' Tommy Taylor 3–0
87' Johnny Berry pen 4–0
Full Time 4–0

Match Facts

Starting XI

Player

5 Jackie Blanchflower

6 Duncan Edwards

7 Johnny Berry 87'

8 William Whelan

9 Tommy Taylor 50', 54', 70'

10 Dennis Viollet

11 David Pegg

Substitutes

Substitutes were not permitted

Managers

MUFC

Matt Busby

Manchester United

OPP

Eric Houghton

Aston Villa

United vs Aston Villa History

Meeting 74 of 203

203

Played

108

Won

Drawn

Lost

376

Goals For

263

Goals Against

All-time record, from the first meeting on Saturday 19th November 1892. After this match United had played Aston Villa 74 times: 33W 12D 29L.

9 Mar 1957 D 1–1 D1 4 May 1957 L 1–2 FAC 5 Oct 1957 W 4–1 D1

22 Oct 1957 W 4–0 This match

31 Mar 1958 L 2–3 D1 26 Dec 1958 W 2–1 D1 27 Dec 1958 W 2–0 D1

All-time	P	W	D	L	F	A	Win%
Home	101	69	19	13	218	91	68.3
Away	99	38	24	37	154	166	38.4
Neutral	3	1	0	2	4	6	33.3

All 203 meetings with Aston Villa →

Match results, lineups and goalscorers compiled from mufcinfo.com; advanced match statistics (xG, shots, possession) via FBref and FotMob where available. Last updated 9 November 2026. How we compile this data →